People who don’t like natural wine say it is faulty. People who love it say it is character. The truth is in the middle: natural wine really is more prone to faults, but not everything that looks odd is a fault. In this guide: the faults worth knowing, how to recognise each one, which of them are still fine, and what to do with a bottle that seems wrong to you.
IN SHORTNatural wine is more prone to faults than conventional wine because it is made without filtering and with little or no sulphur, but not every unusual trait means the wine has gone wrong. The main faults are mousiness, an aftertaste felt only after swallowing that recalls a mouse cage; volatile acidity, a smell of vinegar or nail-polish remover; and brett, smells of sticking plaster or a stable. At low levels, volatile acidity and brett can read as part of a wine’s character, but when they take over the fruit, it is a clear fault. Haze, sediment at the bottom, tartrate crystals or a slight prickle of carbon dioxide, on the other hand, are not faults, and light reductive, sulphurous smells usually pass after airing in the glass or in a decanter.
Why is natural wine more sensitive?
In conventional wine, the sulphur that is added has two main jobs: it protects against oxygen, and it stops unwanted bacteria and yeasts. Natural wine gets little sulphur or none at all, it is not filtered, and it ferments with wild yeasts. All of that is good for the taste, but it leaves less protection.
19 of the 61 wines we sell today are bottled with no added sulphur.
Marto, Piri Naturel, Quantum, Martin Vajčner and Pittnauer. From the winemakers’ data, November 2026
Even with nothing added, the yeasts produce a little sulphur themselves, so a wine with no added sulphur is not entirely sulphur-free. More on it:
the guide to wine with no added sulphur.
What you notice, and what it means
Most of the time you can recognise a fault on the nose or in the mouth, without a lab. This list will help you understand what is in the glass, and what to do about it:
- Mousinessmouse taint
- An aftertaste after swallowing, like a mouse cage or stale popcorn. Lactic acid bacteria or Brett yeasts. You cannot smell it in the glass; it only comes up once the wine mixes with saliva.FaultNothing to be done in the glass. In a young bottle that has been shipped, it sometimes disappears after a few months.
- Volatile acidityVA
- A smell of vinegar or nail-polish remover. Acetic acid and ethyl acetate. A small amount gives a wine freshness and lift.Depends on the amountIf it is in the background, it is character. If it is all you can smell, it is a fault.
- BrettBrettanomyces
- Sticking plaster, medicine, stable, smoke or pungent cheese. Brettanomyces yeasts, mainly in red wines.Depends on the amountSome people like a little. When the fruit disappears behind it, it is a fault.
- Reductionreductive notes
- A struck match, egg, rubber. Sulphur compounds that form when the wine has barely met oxygen.Usually passesSwirl it in the glass, or pour it into a decanter for a quarter of an hour.
- Oxidationoxidative notes
- Bruised apple, nuts, a smell of sherry. Too much oxygen, in the cellar or in the bottle.A fault, unless it is the styleThere is no fix. Some wines aim for it, and the label or the winemaker will tell you.
- Haze and sedimentunfiltered
- A hazy wine, sediment or crystals at the bottom. Unfiltered yeast and grape remains, or tartrate crystals.Not a faultStand the bottle upright and pour gently, or enjoy the texture.
- PrickleCO₂
- A slight prickle in a wine that is meant to be still. Carbon dioxide left over from fermentation. Winemakers sometimes leave it in to protect the wine.Usually not a faultSwirl it in the glass or decant it. If the bottle fizzes hard and gushes, that is fermentation in the bottle.
Mousiness: the fault you can’t smell
Mousiness is the most confusing fault, because there is nothing to smell in the glass. It appears about ten seconds after a sip, as an aftertaste that sticks to the back of the mouth and recalls a mouse cage, stale popcorn or a rice cracker. The reason is chemical: the compounds behind it do not evaporate at the acidity of wine, and are only released when the wine meets saliva, which is less acidic.
They are produced by lactic acid bacteria or Brett yeasts, mainly in wine with low acidity and little free sulphur. According to the research summarised, about 10 milligrams of free sulphur per litre already give good protection. Two more things are worth knowing: mousiness can appear after bottling or shipping, when the wine is stressed by the movement, and it often disappears after a few months or a year in bottle. And not everyone can taste it: the much-quoted figure that about 30% of people cannot taste mousiness is in fact an estimate from 1913.
Volatile acidity: how much vinegar is too much?
Volatile acidity is mainly acetic acid, the acid of vinegar, along with ethyl acetate, which smells like nail-polish remover. Every wine has some. In a small amount it gives a wine freshness, an aroma that leaps out of the glass. In a large amount it turns the wine into vinegar.
The law sets a limit: in the European Union up to about 1.08 grams per litre in white and rosé, and up to about 1.2 grams in red. Tasters start to notice it at around 0.7 grams per litre. In other words, there is a range in which you can taste it, and the wine is still legal and can still be delicious.
Brett: fault or character?
Brett is short for Brettanomyces, yeasts that produce smells of sticking plaster and medicine, of smoke and clove, and of a stable. It shows up mainly in red wines. This is the most argued-about fault: some people like a little "stable" in their wine, and some cannot stand it at all.
The Australian Wine Research Institute found that tasters start to notice it from 368 micrograms per litre in a red wine, and that consumers already liked the wine less at 600. When brett hides the fruit, it is no longer character.
What is not a fault
Haze, sediment and yeast at the bottom of the bottle come from leaving the wine unfiltered, not from anything going wrong (see:
why unfiltered wine is cloudy). Clear crystals at the bottom or on the cork are tartrate crystals, and they are harmless. And a slight prickle in a still wine is usually carbon dioxide left from fermentation; winemakers sometimes leave it in on purpose, because it protects the wine. Swirl the glass, and it is gone.
Received a bottle that seems faulty?
Give it a chance first: swirl it in the glass, and if it smells of a struck match, pour it into a decanter for a quarter of an hour. If there is still a strong smell of vinegar, bruised apple or sticking plaster, or a mousy aftertaste after swallowing, write to us on WhatsApp, and we’ll replace the bottle.
Six wines with no added sulphur
Pét-Nat WeissNahePiri Naturel · no added sulphur, unfiltered. The sediment in the bottle is part of the style.Rose DogmaBurgenlandPittnauer · a rosé from clay amphorae, unfined, unfiltered and with no added sulphur.Sic Semper TyrannisWeinviertelQuantum · orange, a week on the skins, no added sulphur.Fränky BoyWeinviertelQuantum · a chillable red, five days on the skins, no added sulphur.Welschriesling Hnanice IIMoraviaMartin Vajčner · a light, taut white, no added sulphur.MannaRheinhessenMarto · a light red, two years on the lees, no added sulphur. Questions
What is mousiness in wine?
Mousiness is an aftertaste that appears a few seconds after swallowing and recalls a mouse cage, stale popcorn or a rice cracker. It is caused by bacteria or yeasts, mainly in wine with little sulphur, and you cannot smell it in the glass.
Is natural wine more often faulty than conventional wine?
It is more sensitive, because it does not have enough sulphur to protect it from bacteria and oxygen. But a good natural wine is not faulty, and much of what looks odd in natural wine, such as haze or sediment, is not a fault.
How do I know if a natural wine has gone bad?
Smell and taste it. A strong smell of vinegar, bruised apple or sticking plaster that hides the fruit, or a mousy aftertaste after swallowing, are signs of a fault. A hazy look on its own is not a sign that anything is wrong.
What do I do if the wine smells of a struck match?
That is probably reduction, and it usually passes. Swirl the wine in the glass, or pour it into a decanter for a quarter of an hour, and taste again.
What do I do if I received a faulty bottle?
Write to us on WhatsApp, and we’ll replace the bottle.
SOURCES- S. J. Woolf (2024). The complete guide to mousiness. The Morning Claret.
- Which microorganisms contribute to mousy off-flavour in our wines? OENO One.
- AWRI. Brettanomyces: frequently asked questions. Australian Wine Research Institute.
- AWRI. Volatile acidity: fact sheet.
- Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/934, Annex I Part C: maximum volatile acidity.
- MONVIN wine data: the wines on sale with no added sulphur, according to the winemakers. November 2026.